To mcmtanyel: Critique

[ACL1978]

Murat, if you legitimately had nothing to say, you likely should have left it at that. This is less a critique than an attack, and I would argue the shot has more 'to say' than many of your own snapshots. If you want to critique a photo, then do so without attempting to demonstrate your own superiority. Say what you think should be fixed or done differently, and use specifics. A critique like this helps no one, and comes off quite arrogant. Even if you had left off the first part of this, it would have been a more reasonable critique than what it was. But to post something like this, especially on someone's first photo on TE, seems a bit too harsh - we should be welcoming new photographers a bit more openly, don't you think?

Andrew